About Menu Why Us Gallery Location Call (740) 685-2400
Byesville's Neighborhood Pizzeria

Real Pizza,
Real Fresh,
Real Yours.

Hand-tossed dough, locally sourced toppings, and a wood-fired oven that does the talking. At Tommy's, every pie is built the way it should be — no shortcuts, no frozen crusts, just honest food made right in front of you.

Order Now View Menu
100%
Fresh Dough Daily
900°F
Wood-Fired Oven
Local
Sourced Ingredients
Freshly baked pizza pulled from a wood-fired oven at Tommy's Pizza in Byesville Fresh pizza toppings and ingredients on a wooden board Pizza dough being hand-tossed at Tommy's Pizza
Warm interior of Tommy's Pizza restaurant in Byesville with wooden tables and brick oven
Est.
Byesville, OH
Our Story

Not a Franchise. Not a Chain. Just Tommy's.

Tommy's Pizza wasn't born from a business plan — it was born from a belief that the best pizza doesn't need a logo on every corner. It just needs good dough, honest ingredients, and someone who actually cares about the result.

Located right on Main Street in Byesville, we've been serving our neighbors pie after pie, year after year. Our oven runs hot, our dough is mixed every morning, and every order that leaves our counter is one we'd serve our own family.

Locally Owned
Made with Care
Family Friendly
Catering Available
The Difference

Why Byesville Keeps Coming Back

We don't do drive-thrus or apps. We do ovens, ingredients, and people who show up every day and make it count.

Dough Made Every Morning

No frozen par-baked crusts. Our dough is mixed, proofed, and stretched fresh each day — that's non-negotiable.

Toppings You Can Trust

Real vegetables, real cheese, real meat — no processed shortcuts. If it wouldn't sit on your table at home, it doesn't go on our pies.

Wood-Fired Flavor

Our oven hits 900°F, giving every crust that signature char and airy chew you can't replicate any other way.

Right Here in Byesville

We're your neighbors. 222 Main Street — same street you walk every day. This isn't a franchise; it's our community.

What People Say

Loved by Our Neighbors

We don't chase reviews — we chase good pizza. But our regulars aren't shy about sharing their thoughts.

"Best pizza in Byesville, hands down. The crust is always perfect — crispy on the outside, soft on the inside. We come here every Friday night and it never disappoints."

Sarah M.
Byesville Resident

"You can tell they actually care about what they're making. The ingredients taste fresh, the portions are generous, and the atmosphere is exactly what a neighborhood spot should feel like."

James T.
Local Customer

"We ordered catering for our family reunion and everyone was asking where we got the pizza. Tommy's delivered exactly what they promised — hot, fresh, and absolutely delicious."

Linda R.
Byesville Local
Find Us

Visit Tommy's on Main Street

Get in Touch

Address
222 Main St, Byesville 43723
Hours
Mon–Thu: 11am – 9pm
Fri–Sat: 11am – 10pm
Sunday: 12pm – 8pm
Ordering
Call ahead for pickup
Walk-ins welcome

Hungry? Give Us a Call.

Pickup or dine-in — we're ready when you are. Order ahead and skip the wait.

(740) 685-2400
Is this your business?This is my business